A Miami judge has dismissed a lawsuit filed against Royal Caribbean by
the family of a man who disappeared from a honeymoon cruise.
Judge Jon I. Gordon granted a motion Monday to dismiss the lawsuit
faulting Royal Caribbean International for its handling of George A.
Smith IV's disappearance more than a year ago.
"It's a setback, of course, but it's not the end," maritime lawyer Brett
Rivkind told Greenwich Time on Thursday. "The Smith family isn't
discouraged. Whether the Smith family won or lost, the issue is going to
be decided in an appellate court."
Royal Caribbean welcomed the dismissal.
"For some time, we have said that a fair, accurate and objective review
of the facts would clearly demonstrate that the lawsuit was completely
baseless," the Miami-based cruise line said in a statement. "The court's
decision upholds the validity of our position. Although we will not be
surprised if the suit is refiled in some amended fashion, we are
confident that the outcome will be the same. We continue to extend our
sympathies to the Smith family for the tragic loss of their son."
Smith, of Greenwich, disappeared from the Brilliance of the Seas while
on a honeymoon cruise in the Aegean Sea on July 5, 2005. His body was
not recovered, though bloodstains were found on an awning underneath the
newlywed's cabin balcony.
The FBI is still investigating.
His disappearance became one of the most publicized cases of a missing
passenger aboard a cruise ship, sparking congressional hearings on
maritime security and a federal bill requiring cruise lines to report
cases of missing passengers and crimes to the Department of Homeland
Security.
Smith's parents and sister believe the 26-year-old Greenwich man was
murdered, and allege in their lawsuit filed in June that the cruise
company tried to cover up the incident to avoid liability and negative
publicity.
Royal Caribbean representatives have said the cruise line exceeded its
legal requirements when it contacted the FBI and other authorities
immediately after learning about Smith's disappearance.