I think that reading the reviews can be helpful, but I need to get beyond "the average". That is, if six out of eight people rate the food as bad, I certainly believe that in their opinion it was bad. I recall, however, that my brother could not eat anything but hamburgers and french fries well into his thirties (why he made it into his forties is beyond me). But obviously, we tailor our review toward what we are used to and are expecting.
I also like to know the age of the people involved, especially when services, food, night life, activities and so forth are rated and an average rating is presented. I'm truly not much interested in the things a 22-year old is. I'm not in the shuffleboard set, but I don't climb walls (I did enough of that when I was an engineer!) I think the best review is one that comes from an individual whose tastes you understand and whose opinion you trust. Latch onto that review!
Then book the cruise anyway. At least that way, you're offshore! :biggrin: