Best Cabins

Mebert · November 25, 2005

Vote for the best cabins.

KeithnRita · November 26, 2005

We voted Carnival. The biggest and best outside cabin for us was on the Victory.

Lisa63 · November 26, 2005

I narrowed it down to Royal Caribbean and Carnival, and gave the slight edge to Royal Caribbean solely for decor. Our inside cabins on Royal Caribbean were spacious and comfortable and had more storage space than our family of three needed. I also loved having the sofabed on both Royal Caribbean and Carnival, even though we weren't in a top category.

Our cabin on HAL was also nice, yet there aren't many good locations for a standard outside cabin on the S-class ships.

JoeyandDavid · November 26, 2005

we went with HAL on this one

Shari2 · November 26, 2005

I went with Celebrity again, but Carnival has nice cabins...we just weren't able at that time, to have a balcony cabin, so my favorite cabin was on "Infinity."

gymbrat33 · November 27, 2005

I voted for Carnival. Am I the only one who has only sailed on one cruise line?

I'm going to start a new poll on how many cruise lines have you sailed on?

DaCruzNut · November 28, 2005

Carnival may be lacking in some areas, but they win in this category 'hands down.'

Joanandjoe · November 28, 2005

No vote here, Mebert! As we mentioned on our post when you asked for nominations, none of the listed choices compares with the standard cabins on Radisson. Ditto food, service, etc. However, as we noted, so few people on this board have sailed on Radisson, Seaboard, Sea Dream, Silversea, or Windstar that those lines don't have any chance of winning these polls. I guess that's why our nominations didn't make the final cut.

Of the two lines we've tried out of your six nominees, we liked the rooms on HAL (NOT Vista class!) more than on Celebrity, largely because they have bathtubs and most rooms on Celebity do not. Also, the HAL rooms were larger and were better decorated.