Man sues after entire staff stuck on cruise. Justified or not?

[Jason]

A Beaumont eye care business and a group of cruise ship passengers have filed separate lawsuits against Carnival Cruise Lines in connection with the ill-fated Carnival Triumph voyage in February.

Dr. Peter Cass, who owns and operates Beaumont Family Eye Care, filed a lawsuit Aug. 8 to recoup losses to his business stemming from the cruise ship's problems.

Three days after leaving Galveston on Feb. 7 for Mexico, a fire ignited in the Triumph's engine room, disabling the vessel's propulsion system and knocking out power. The cruise ship drifted for days in the Gulf of Mexico before it was towed to Mobile, Ala., on Feb. 14.

Cass took his entire staff on a cruise aboard Carnival Triumph, and suffered economic losses due to the five-day delay in getting the employees back to reopen the business.

"This is purely an economic loss claim," said Beaumont attorney Matthew C. Matheny, who represents the eye center. "Dr. Cass actually took his entire office on a paid vacation, including some of their spouses. They were stranded out there and had to shut down the business for more than a week."

Cass also chartered a bus to get his staffers back to work, and sustained additional expenses with contract labor, Matheny said.

The lawsuit alleges that the cruise line was aware of the mechanical problems aboard the ship and failed to maintain the vessel "in a reasonable and safe manner to prevent a fire in the engine room." The cruise line also failed warn passengers of the danger, the lawsuit states.

In a separate lawsuit also filed Aug. 8, some passengers who were aboard the Triumph claim that they exposed to urine and feces and the odors of raw sewage that leaked through the ceilings, walls and floors.

The federal lawsuit also alleges that passengers were exposed to extreme heat and cold temperatures and had to wait in long lines to get water and food.

The lawsuit, filed by Beaumont attorney T. Roebuck, alleges that Carnival was negligent for failing to maintain the vessel in a reasonable and safe manner, for failing to hire and supervise competent management, and for failing to provide sanitary accommodations, adequate food and drinking water, and ventilation.

The lawsuit seeks an award of damages for discomfort, medical expenses, mental anguish and lost earnings, and out-of-pocket expenses.

Carnival spokesman Vance Gulliksen declined to comment about the lawsuits.

By Robert Stanton, Beaumont Enterprise

For more cruise news & articles go to http://www.cruisecrazies.com/index.html

Re-posted on CruiseCrazies.com - Cruise News, Articles, Forums, Packing List, Ship Tracker, and more

http://www.cruisecrazies.com

Click here to view the article

[Sarge6870]

"Dr. Cass actually took his entire office on a paid vacation, including some of their spouses." If the doctor can afford this, he can afford to lose a few days of the office being closed. He's an eye doctor, not a heart surgeon!! Just sayin'!! Get over it doc........

[DebbieandJerry]

Exactly what I was thinking. If he can afford to take his entire business on a paid cruise vacation, he can afford to lose a few days of work.

So, if it was just him on this cruise, would he have filed a law suit?

[Huntm]

I don't agree with it either. He didn't mind losing business for the week he closed to go on vacation. It was an unforseen circumstance and risk you take when you cruise.

[WeCruiseToo]

The lawsuit seeks an award of damages for discomfort

Wait, you can sue for being uncomfortable? I think I’ve missed out on filing lots of lawsuits...

[jacketwatch]

Our law suit happy society in action again .

when our son was 18 he got into an accident driving one of our cars in a collision with a motorcycle. The driver of the bike settled with the ins. co. right away but his passenger thought a broken toe and a few stitches was worth the limits of his policy, 250K. She sued and ended up 17 k in the hole for non justified medical claims and follow up tests, consults etc. for phantom symptoms. Serves her right!

Some see it as unfortunate and accept the appropriate compensation offered. Others see it as a get rich opportunity.

[Sarge6870]

It's sad Larry!! I've heard stories of how people actually make a living by law suits!! And the lawyers would rather not have to go to court and incur the added time and expense so the seem to always opt for out of court settlements. And who pays for it all? WE do!! In higher insurance premiums!!!